A softer lash. A little more you.
Red hair comes in copper, strawberry, auburn, cinnamon, and a hundred beautiful variations. Your mascara gets to have personality, too.
Here’s how to choose brown, auburn, plum or black without turning your hair color into a rule book.

Photo by Gabriel Silvério / Unsplash. Editorial stock image; not Mary and not a product-results photograph.
What color mascara is best for redheads? Start with brown for soft definition, auburn or chestnut for warmth beside naturally pale lashes, plum or burgundy for a playful hint of color, and black for stronger contrast. Your own lash color, eye color and preferred look matter more than any one-size-fits-all rule.
Makeup artists interviewed by IPSY discuss brown as a natural-looking daily option, while berry shades can be an interesting alternative to black. And as Elite Daily points out, different redheads may enjoy different levels of contrast. That’s exactly where this guide begins: with what you want to see in the mirror.
Brown, auburn, plum or black? Your mascara color guide
Brown / espresso
Try warm true brown for a lighter, natural-looking lash line. A darker espresso shade gives a bit more definition without going all the way to black.
Auburn / chestnut
Warm red-browns can make pale natural lashes more visible without feeling like a dramatic change. They can be beautiful with copper or strawberry hair.
Plum / burgundy
Berry and violet undertones add interest. On some lashes, plum reads like a deep neutral; on others, the color becomes much more apparent.
Black
Black creates a crisp lash line and is absolutely an option for redheads. It’s especially fitting when you want a bolder makeup look.
The colored circles are design illustrations, not exact product swatches or guarantees of how a formula will look.
Consider your natural lashes before your hair
Two people may have nearly identical auburn hair and completely different lash colors. One has dark lashes that are visible without anything on them. Another has pale blonde tips that seem to disappear unless mascara is involved. They might want different formulas and different amounts of contrast.
If your natural lashes are very light, a warm brown, auburn or chestnut can be a gentle place to start. If you have darker lashes, espresso or black might blend into your usual look. If you love high contrast, wear black. The goal is makeup that feels like yours.
One small technique to try: a black mascara on the upper lashes and a brown shade on the lower lashes can soften the result without losing definition. Maybelline suggests that approach in its brown-mascara guide.

Give that first coat a chance.
Start with clean lashes and a light, even coat at the roots. Sweep gently upward without poking or pulling. Look at your lashes before adding another coat: is there enough contrast? Do they look separated? Do you like the color in daylight?
A soft brown can still give beautiful definition. More mascara isn’t always the answer when the color itself is exactly right.
Mascara for redheads with green, blue or brown eyes
Eye color offers inspiration, not a test you have to pass. There isn’t a universal color combination that flatters everyone, but these are good places to experiment:
- Green or hazel eyes: Plum or burgundy can provide berry-toned contrast. Brown and auburn are softer options.
- Blue eyes: Warm brown and chestnut create gentle definition; black gives you a stronger frame.
- Brown eyes: Espresso, auburn, plum or black can all work, depending on how subtle or bold you want the lashes to look.
Some days you’ll want a soft daytime face, and some days you’ll want the lashes to show up from the other end of the dinner table. Both can be perfectly lovely choices.
Three real mascara shades worth knowing about
A search for “mascara for redheads” can quickly become an endless scroll of vague promises. To make this practical, here are some specific shades listed by Maybelline for its Lash Sensational Sky High Washable Mascara at the time of our research:
True Brown: The brand describes this as a warm dark brown—a useful starting point if you want softer everyday definition.
Burgundy Haze: A deeper burgundy shade when you want a berry tone rather than a traditional neutral.
Plum Twilight: A dark purple option for a different kind of contrast, especially if you enjoy colored mascara.
These are manufacturer-verified shade examples, not mascaras Mary has personally tested. Names and availability may change. Check the shade and retailer listing before purchasing.
For more specialized shades, the makeup publication How to Be a Redhead describes auburn, chestnut, brown, black and plum mascara options. Some specialty colors may be preorder-only, so double-check availability rather than assuming they’re ready to ship.
Redheads can absolutely wear black mascara
Sometimes you want subtle definition. Sometimes you want a bold lash line. Black mascara can be the right choice if you like a crisp contrast, defined brows or a more dramatic eye. Red hair doesn’t take that option away.
Mary’s personal favorite is YOUNIQUE QUADRA 4-in-1 Mascara, and she especially loves the curl and lift she gets from it. QUADRA is a jet-black mascara, so it’s relevant here for someone who specifically wants that darker effect. Mary is not a redhead, and this is not presented as her having performed a redhead shade test.
Affiliate disclosure: Minute With Mary may receive compensation from qualifying purchases made through CURATED links. Products cited for their color selections elsewhere in this guide are research examples, not personal product endorsements.
Want curl, lift and bold black lashes?
Explore QUADRA, or visit the Mascara Made Easy guide to compare different formula types.
A quick five-step way to find your shade
- Check your natural lashes. Are they nearly blonde, a warm brown or already dark?
- Decide how much contrast you want. Softer brown and auburn are one route; plum and black make different statements.
- Choose a formula you enjoy. Length, separation, curling and removal matter just as much as pigment color.
- Apply one controlled coat in daylight. Let the color show you what it does before adding more.
- Adjust on your next purchase. Go warmer and lighter for less contrast, deeper for more definition.
Frequently asked questions
Is brown mascara better than black for redheads?
Brown often gives a softer result; black gives more contrast. Your natural lashes, your eye makeup and your personal preference decide which is better for you.
What color should I try if my eyelashes are very light?
Try a warm brown, chestnut or auburn first if you want a subtle look. If you want stronger definition, consider espresso or black.
Can redheads wear plum mascara?
Of course. Plum and burgundy are appealing alternatives if you like a hint of color. Their appearance changes with the formula and the lighting.
What about red hair and green eyes?
Brown, auburn and plum are all worth considering. Plum adds more contrast; a warm brown can look more understated.
Has Mary personally tested every color in this guide?
No. This is a research-informed shade guide, and no redhead-specific product trials are claimed. Mary’s direct experience relates to QUADRA’s curl and lift, not a test of brown, auburn or plum shades.
Find your next beauty minute
Need more help choosing a formula? Start with Mascara Made Easy. Want to know what gives straight lashes curl? Visit What Mascara Holds a Curl?. And Mary’s current beauty picks are always there when you’re ready to explore.
Sources: IPSY makeup-color guidance; Elite Daily redhead mascara discussion; Maybelline shade listings; How to Be a Redhead. Illustrative photos: Gabriel Silvério, Annie Spratt, and featured-image photographer Houcine Ncib / Unsplash. Stock models aren’t Mary, product testers or representatives of the listed mascaras.