The beauty library / no. 01

Mascara, made easy.

Length. Lift. A little everyday drama. Here’s how to choose the mascara that makes sense for your lashes and the look you actually want.

Start with your goal: curl, volume, definition, color or easier removal. The formula and brush are worth considering, and a lighter application can make all the difference when your lashes tend to fall flat.

01 / THE EVERYDAY EDIT

YOUNIQUE QUADRA 4-in-1 mascara and wand on a white background
Real-life lashes. Personal favorites.

01 / start with the result

What do you want your lashes to do?

Choosing a mascara is easier when you give it a job. A giant brush and a dramatic promise may be tempting, but what works for one person’s lashes may feel completely different on yours. Here are six reasonable starting points.

01 — LIFT

Curl & lift

If straight lashes don’t like to stay up, look for lightweight, buildable formulas and brushes that help you work at the base. Extra-thick coats can work against that lifted shape.

MARY’S GO-TO GOAL

02 — DEFINITION

Length & separation

Consider a comb-like or well-spaced brush that helps coat each lash. Buildable formulas can add definition without making every lash meet its neighbor.

LOOK FOR: A CONTROLLED WAND

03 — IMPACT

Volume & drama

Fuller-looking lashes may be your goal. Try one even coat before building more, and check whether a thicker formula feels comfortable on your natural lashes.

LOOK FOR: BUILDABLE VOLUME

04 — WEAR

Less smudging

If you regularly find mascara below your eyes, consider a tubing formula or another transfer-resistant option. Eye-area products, skin oils and application all affect wear.

LOOK FOR: YOUR WEAR NEEDS

05 — COLOR

Softer color

Black makes an impact; brown, auburn and plum can create a softer contrast when those shades are available. Your preferred look matters more than a rigid rule about eye or hair color.

LOOK FOR: SHADE OPTIONS

06 — EASY OFF

Gentler removal

Some tubing formulas are designed to release with warm water and light pressure. Check the exact product instructions and avoid rubbing at the delicate eye area.

LOOK FOR: REMOVAL INSTRUCTIONS

A helpful rule of thumb: you don’t need the most elaborate routine to make a difference. Decide what matters to you first, then choose a product and an application technique that help you get there. One coat you love beats three you wish you’d stopped at.

02 / know your formula

Three mascara types worth understanding.

You’ll see terms like curling, volumizing, tubing and waterproof on product pages. They describe different features, and some products fit more than one category. The label is a starting point, not a prediction of your personal results.

The classic

Regular mascara

Traditional washable mascaras come in a wide range of textures, brushes and finishes. The right one may give you exactly the definition or volume you’re looking for; check its removal directions.

The wraparound

Tubing mascara

Tubing formulas use polymers designed to form tiny sleeves around lashes. Many focus on definition and smudge resistance, with warm-water removal. Tubing alone does not guarantee curl hold.

The weather-ready

Waterproof mascara

Some people find waterproof formulas help when lashes struggle to stay lifted or conditions are wet. They may require a dedicated remover, and comfort varies by formula.

Think of these as shopping categories, not hard rules. Ingredients, brushes, directions and individual preferences differ. For sensitive eyes or contact-lens concerns, check with your eye-care professional rather than relying on a marketing label.

03 / the everyday technique

A mascara routine you can actually repeat.

It’s easy to add too much product while chasing a little extra lift. Start with a controlled first coat, then decide whether you need anything more.

01.

Start clean.

Begin with clean, dry lashes and a clean wand. Old mascara can make fresh application uneven. Skip a formula that has dried out or smells or feels unusual.

02.

Curl first, if you use a curler.

For a traditional lash curler, gently curl before applying mascara. Avoid pulling and never clamp onto dry, stiff mascara-coated lashes.

03.

Begin near the roots.

With a steady hand and your eye safely clear of the applicator, set the wand near the base of the lashes and move upward, coating them without poking or tugging.

04.

Give that first coat a chance.

Check the separation and lift before going back for more. Sometimes one well-placed coat gets you there faster than layering until the lashes feel heavy.

05.

Remove it before bed.

Follow the product’s instructions and be gentle around your eyes. Don’t share mascara, and replace older eye makeup regularly to help reduce contamination.

Mary’s personal favoriteSilver QUADRA mascara tube with wand and black mascara swoosh

04 / from Mary’s makeup bag

Meet QUADRA.

Mary loves QUADRA for the curl and lift she gets from it. It’s her favorite mascara.

YOUNIQUE describes QUADRA 4-in-1 as a combined serum, primer, tubing formula and mascara. The company markets lift, length and volume benefits; those are manufacturer descriptions, while Mary’s curl-and-lift enthusiasm is her own experience.

Different lashes respond differently, and we aren’t claiming a specific number of hours of curl retention or a head-to-head win over every other mascara. The useful question is whether the formula matches your everyday lash goals.

Affiliate disclosure: We may receive compensation from purchases made through CURATED links.

Transparency note: Minute With Mary may receive compensation from qualifying purchases through CURATED links. Mary’s reported favorite is a personal preference, not independent comparative testing. Prices and availability are subject to change.

05 / explore the library

One good question leads to another.

Want to get a little more specific? Follow the subject that matches your lashes. You’ll also find Mary’s original mascara tutorials below—they’re part of her beauty story, even though the products and offers in those older posts may have changed.

Curl & lift / application guide

What mascara holds a curl?

A closer look at straight lashes, formula weight, curl technique and why Mary especially loves QUADRA for lift.

Read the curl and lift guide →

Shade guide / red hair

Mascara for redheads.

How to think about black, brown, auburn and plum. Compare brown, auburn, plum and black, with real shade examples and advice for different lash colors.

Read the redhead mascara guide →

On the editorial calendar / formulas

Tubing vs. regular mascara.

A plain-English look at what changes with tubing formulas, how removal works and which trade-offs matter.

Research in progress

Shop the current edit / curated

Mary’s Picks.

Browse the beauty shelf Mary is sharing now, including QUADRA and the Everyday Six. Product links and selections live in one easy place.

Explore the current picks →

From the MWM archives / 2017

A little beauty housekeeping

Keep those lashes happy.

Eye makeup hygiene is worth a minute, too. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration recommends replacing mascara after three months, not sharing eye cosmetics, and never adding water or saliva to dried-out mascara. Stop using a product if it causes irritation; if the irritation persists, talk with a healthcare professional. For more guidance on removing eye makeup gently, see the American Academy of Ophthalmology.

06 / the quick answers

A few lash questions, answered.

What mascara is best for straight lashes?

Start with a formula built for curl or lift and a brush that helps you reach the lash base without heavy layering. A lightweight first coat often makes evaluating curl easier. Mary loves QUADRA for the curl and lift it gives her, but the best fit for you will depend on your own lashes and routine.

Is tubing mascara better than regular mascara?

Not universally. Tubing products are designed to coat lashes with polymer sleeves and often appeal to people who want definition and less smudging. Traditional formulas vary widely, and some offer a different balance of volume, removal and finish. Choose by your goal and the actual product instructions.

Does waterproof mascara always hold curl better?

No product category gives everyone the same result. Some people prefer a waterproof formula for stubborn lashes or wet conditions, but removal can take more care. Compare what your own lashes do rather than relying on one label.

Should I curl my eyelashes before applying mascara?

If you use a traditional eyelash curler, curl gently on clean lashes before application. Stop if there’s pinching or pulling, and follow the tool’s safety directions. You may also decide you like the lift from your mascara alone.

Does mascara color have to match my hair color?

Not at all. Black delivers contrast, while softer brown or auburn shades can create a subtler look when those colors are available. Your own taste is the deciding factor. We’re researching a dedicated redhead shade guide to help compare the options.

How often should I replace mascara?

The FDA recommends discarding mascara about three months after purchase, and sooner if it becomes contaminated or you develop an eye infection. Never try to revive a dried-out tube with water or saliva.

Your next minute starts here

Good lashes. Real life. Your way.

Now that you know what to look for, explore Mary’s current makeup edit. Shop if something fits your routine, or come back whenever you’re ready for another little beauty lesson.

With love from Minute With Mary

Explore Mary’s Picks ↗